| Premier Organization | School |
|---|
| Jonathan Palumbo | Ontario Terriers | Davenport | 2012 |
| Kolton Babb | Kansas City Sluggers | Evangel | 2011 |
| Tanner Baker | Kansas City Sluggers | Benedictine | 2011 |
| Nick Deichler | Kansas City Sluggers | Ottawa | 2011 |
| Joshua Powe | Albuquerque Baseball Academy | Lubbock Christian | 2011 |
| Jacob Powell | Kansas City Sluggers | York | 2011 |
| Jacob Skorka | Albuquerque Baseball Academy | Arts and Sciences Oklahoma | 2011 |
| Destul Huff | Cincy Flames | Cumberlands | 2010 |
| Tavis Bruce | Ontario Terriers | UBC | 2009 |
| Noah Buettgen | Cincy Flames | Lincoln Trail | 2009 |
| Blake Castator | Cincy Flames | Cumberlands | 2009 |
| Robbie Nesteroff | Cincy Flames | Cedarville | 2009 |
| Adam Poff | Cincy Flames | Shawnee State | 2009 |
| Graeme Scott | Ontario Terriers | Trinity Christian | 2009 |
| Darren Aggus | Midwest Nationals | College of Ozarks | 2008 |
| David Blount | Houston Heat | College of Ozarks | 2008 |
| Graeme Carey | Ontario Terriers | UBC | 2008 |
| Zach Craig | Midwest Nationals | College of Ozarks | 2008 |
| Tyler Hartley | Midwest Nationals | College of Ozarks | 2008 |
| Nathan Loehle | Ontario Terriers | Bellevue | 2008 |
| Dustin Loggins | Midwest Nationals | College of Ozarks | 2008 |
| Kevin Nickel | Ontario Terriers | UBC | 2008 |
| Brett Richardson | Midwest Nationals | College of Ozarks | 2008 |
| Jared Richmond | Midwest Nationals | Tusculum College | 2008 |
| Kevin Stephens | Arlington A's | UTexas-Permian Basin | 2008 |
| Dustin Williams | Midwest Nationals | Oklahoma City University | 2008 |
| Denton Wolf | Midwest Nationals | College of Ozarks | 2008 |
| Martin Adams | Premier Titans | College of Southwest | 2007 |
| Nick Ashford | Arlington A's | Southwestern University | 2007 |
| Drew Blair | Albuquerque Baseball Academy | Mansfield University | 2007 |
| Jared Carter | Midwest Nationals | Evangel University | 2007 |
| Nick Cox | Arlington A's | Southwestern University | 2007 |
| Bridges Crumpler | Premier Titans | Wayland Baptist University | 2007 |
| Cooper Dodd | Arlington A's | Texas Wesleyan | 2007 |
| Josh Fant | Arlington A's | Texas College | 2007 |
| Brantley Freeman | Arlington A's | Southwestern University | 2007 |
| Tad Gass | Arlington A's | Wayland Baptist University | 2007 |
| Aaron Glover | Arlington A's | Wayland Baptist University | 2007 |
| Eric Kegley | Arlington A's | Southwestern University | 2007 |
| Chase LaPenna | Arlington A's | Howard Payne University | 2007 |
| David Lovet | Albuquerque Baseball Academy | Kansas Weslyan | 2007 |
| Eric Roten | Arlington A's | Hardin Simmons University | 2007 |
| Mike Sobel | LIDS Indiana Bulls | Northern Kentucky | 2007 |
| Travis Street | Dallas Mustangs | Ottawa | 2007 |
| Colby Tomasi | Arlington A's | Texas Wesleyan | 2007 |
| Mike Valdez | Arlington A's | Texas Wesleyan | 2007 |
| Justin Van | Premier Titans | Sul Ross University | 2007 |
| Wayne Warren | Dallas Mustangs | Trinity | 2007 |
| Jameson Williamson | Arlington A's | Texas Wesleyan | 2007 |
